Blog Layout

Bad trustee behaviour can lead to disqualification
Liz Gibbs • March 6, 2019

For many Australians, the control and flexibility offered by an SMSF makes this an attractive option for managing their superannuation. However, being an SMSF trustee carries significant responsibilities. In a case last year ( Hart and Commissioner of Taxation ), the Administrative Appeals Tribunal underlined the consequences that can flow when SMSF trustees do not take their responsibilities seriously.

The facts

A married couple were the trustees and members of their SMSF. After their marriage broke down in 2012, the SMSF's auditor notified the ATO that the fund had breached a superannuation law. An ATO audit then uncovered many more compliance issues. Some of the activities that concerned the ATO included:

  • a supposed "investment" by the SMSF in a related Philippines company, where the face value of the issued shares was a fraction of the $100,000 paid for them;
  • withdrawal of other moneys without meeting any condition of release;
  • the husband declaring the wife's benefits in the SMSF had been "forfeited"; and
  • the transfer of the couple's "hobby farm" into the SMSF that was, among many issues, not correctly registered in the name of the trustees and not transferred at market value.

These actions involved serious alleged breaches of numerous superannuation laws. Ultimately, the Commissioner exercised his power to disqualify the husband from being a trustee of a superannuation fund. The husband applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Commissioner's decision.

The Tribunal's findings

By law, the Commissioner may disqualify a person if either the number or seriousness of the person's contraventions of superannuation law justifies their disqualification or the person is not a "fit and proper person" to be a trustee.

The Tribunal said the first ground was met because it was "abundantly clear" the husband had breached superannuation laws numerous times and the breaches were "extremely serious". The Tribunal also found that the husband unquestionably failed the alternative "fit and proper person" test.

Notably, the Tribunal had observed that the husband gave "less than satisfactory" answers and tried to deflect responsibility or confuse the issues. They also noted that he was not candid when dealing with the ATO.and that there was a "serious suspicion" that he had falsified signatures on documents. The Tribunal therefore affirmed the Commissioner's decision to disqualify the husband from acting as an SMSF trustee again.

Lessons for SMSF trustees

This decision highlights the importance of honesty and cooperation when dealing with the ATO during an audit, and also that the ATO and courts will not look favourably upon SMSF trustees whose ignorance of the law and behaviour indicate they are not a "fit and proper person" to be a trustee.

Understand your responsibilities

In order to hold benefits in an SMSF, you must be prepared to genuinely undertake trusteeship of the fund. Contact our office if you are considering establishing an SMSF and need more information about the duties and responsibilities of SMSF trustees.

© Copyright 2019. All rights reserved. Source: Thomson Reuters.   IMPORTANT: This communication is factual only and does not constitute financial advice. Please consult a licensed financial planner for advice tailored to your financial circumstances . Brought to you by Robert Goodman Accountants.  

Office open
By Liz Gibbs March 10, 2025
With thanks to all Energex and Emergency services Crew, our electricity has been reconnected and our office is open from today 11 March. We hope you and your loved ones are safe and well following cyclone Alfred. These past few days have been challenging for many, and our thoughts are with everyone affected.
By Liz Gibbs March 10, 2025
Due to a power outage affecting the entire Samford area, the RGA Practice will be operating remotely today, 10 March, until electricity is restored. Please be assured that our team remains available and can be reached at 07 3289 1700. We appreciate your understanding and support during this time. Stay safe, and we look forward to seeing you soon.
Cyclone Alfred
By Liz Gibbs March 5, 2025
As Tropical Cyclone Alfred approaches, we want to remind everyone to take necessary precautions and ensure their safety. We have received some important information that we believe is crucial to share with you to help you prepare for the severe weather conditions ahead.
Work Health and Safety (Sexual Harassment) Amendment Regulation 2024
By Liz Gibbs February 26, 2025
In a significant move to combat workplace sexual harassment, Amendments to the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (as per the Work Health and Safety (Sexual Harassment) Amendment Regulation 2024) will soon commence on 1 March 2025.
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
The amount of money that can be transferred to a tax-free retirement account will increase to $2m on 1 July 2025.
What happens to your super when you die?
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
The Government has announced its intention to introduce mandatory standards for large superannuation funds to, amongst other things, deliver timely and compassionate handling of death benefits. Do we have a problem with paying out super when a member dies?
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
If credit card surcharges are banned in other countries, why not Australia? We look at the surcharge debate and the payment system complexity that has brought us to this point. In the United Kingdom, consumer credit and debit card surcharges have been banned since 2018. In Europe, all except American Express and Diners Club consumer surcharges are banned. And in Australia, there is a push to follow suit. But, is the issue as simple as it seems?
Babyboomer wealth
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
“Succession planning, and the tax risks associated with it, is our number one focus in 2025. In recent years we’ve observed an increase in reorganisations that appear to be connected to succession planning.” ATO Private Wealth Deputy Commissioner Louise Clarke.
Penalty for False R&D claims
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
A joint investigation involving the ATO found that, between 2014 and 2017, a Sydney business coach promoted unlawful tax schemes encouraging clients to lodge over-inflated, inaccurate or unsubstantiated research and development ('R&D') tax incentive claims
SMSF lodgement due dates
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
All trustees of SMSFs with assets (including super contributions or any other investments) as at 30 June 2024 need to lodge an SMSF annual return ('SAR') for the 2023/24 financial year.
More Posts
Share by: