Has your employer underpaid super?
Liz Gibbs • January 4, 2021

Are you an employee that has been underpaid super by your employer? If you think that's the case, and you're keen to claw back what's rightfully yours, there's a few routes you can take. Perhaps the easiest way, provided you have the proper documentation, is to lodge a super enquiry with the ATO. Most complaints lodged with the ATO will need to relate to underpaid super within the last 5 years and the enquiry process is expected to take 12 months or longer to resolve, so you'll need to act quickly to start the process or risk missing out.

If you're an individual and you think you've been underpaid or not paid super for the work you've done, one of the ways to try to claim unpaid super is to lodge an enquiry with the ATO. While there are other ways to pursue your claim such as going to the Fair Work Ombudsman or through the Courts, going through the ATO may be the easiest way, provided you have the proper documentation.

In order to lodge a claim, first you need to work out whether you were entitled to be paid super. For example, if you didn't earn $450 or more (before tax) in a calendar month, your employer is not required to pay super. If you've determined that you are entitled to be paid super, the next step is to check myGov to ensure that your employer hasn't paid super to their default fund.

When you've confirmed that you're both entitled to be paid super and that amount of super has not been paid or has been underpaid, you can lodge an enquiry with the ATO containing the following information:

  • invoices, claim for payments and/or any other payment documentation;
  • payslip, payment summaries or income statements from the employer;
  • copies of super fund statements for the years in question, plus a further 6 months;
  • the employer's contact details including business address;
  • the employer's ABN; and
  • details outlining the period of unpaid super including when the issue started and ended (ie month and year).

In addition to the information above, the ATO is also likely to seek permission from you to use your name when contacting your employer and in some instances may not be able to proceed with the super enquiry (or there may be delays) if permission is not provided.

If you have an enquiry regarding unpaid or underpaid super that relate to more than 5 years ago, it may be more difficult if not impossible for the ATO to deal with. The ATO notes that unless you have documentary evidence that your employer has not met their super guarantee obligations, it cannot investigate further.

Even in instances where you have the documentary evidence, the ATO notes there is no guarantee that the enquiry can be progressed "due to the timeframe", however, you will generally receive a letter within 28 days advising whether the investigation will commence, allowing you to explore other alternative options.

For enquiries relating to less than 5 years ago, once you lodge your documents, the ATO will contact you as it moves through each of the 5 stages (query received, investigation progressing, employer debt established, debt collection progressing and query closed). Contact will mainly be in the form of mail or email through the myGov portal.

When the "employer debt established" stage is reached, you will receive an estimate from the ATO based on the information received so far. However, the actual amount paid into your super fund may differ from the estimate provided due to the accrual of interest or in instances where your previous employer provides new information. Remember to be patient if you're pursuing the enquiry route through the ATO, the entire process is expected to take 12 months or longer.

Need help?

Do you need help to work out whether you have unpaid or whether your employer has underpaid you super? We have the expertise to help you work it out and submit any enquiries with the ATO on your behalf. Contact us today to take out all the hard work of dealing with the Tax Office.

Email us at Robert Goodman Accountants at 
© Copyright 2021 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Brought to you by Robert Goodman Accountants.
Superannuation Guarantee
By Liz Gibbs April 17, 2025
The superannuation guarantee rules are broad and, in some circumstances, extend beyond the definition of common law employees to some directors, contractors, entertainers, sports persons and other workers.
time management
By Liz Gibbs April 15, 2025
If your to-do list is starting to look more like a novel than a plan for the day, you’re not alone. It’s all too easy to get bogged down by endless tasks, unsure where to start or what really deserves your attention. That’s where the “Must, Should, Could” method comes in—a brilliantly simple way to cut through the clutter and focus on what truly matters.
Solid Business Foundations
By Liz Gibbs April 11, 2025
When it comes to improving your business, think of it like building a house. You wouldn’t add a second floor without ensuring the foundation is rock-solid, right? The same goes for your business.
Personal tax cut
By Liz Gibbs April 10, 2025
On the last sitting day of Parliament, the personal income tax rate reduction announced in the 2025-26 Federal Budget was confirmed.
How does FBT work
By Liz Gibbs March 31, 2025
An overview of FBT. Find out how FBT applies, what you need to do as an employer, and what deductions you can claim.
Odometer readings
By Liz Gibbs March 30, 2025
The Australian Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT) year runs from 1 April to 31 March, and one of the key compliance requirements for employers providing motor vehicles to employees is recording odometer readings on 31 March each year. These readings help determine the taxable value of car fringe benefits and ensure accurate FBT calculations.
Monthly GST Reporting for Small Businesses
By Liz Gibbs March 25, 2025
From 1 April 2025, the ATO will be moving around 3,500 small businesses from quarterly to monthly GST reporting where they have a history of: ❌ non-payment; ❌ late or non-lodgment; or ❌ incorrect reporting. Once the change is implemented, it will remain in place for a minimum of 12 months. Affected small businesses and their tax agents will be contacted by the ATO when their GST reporting cycle is changed. A review process is available for those who don’t believe they have a history of poor compliance and should be able to remain on their current GST reporting cycle. The ATO believes that this will help small businesses improve compliance with their GST obligations and build good business habits. Do you think this is a good move?
Budget 2025-26:
By Liz Gibbs March 25, 2025
In Part 3 of our analysis, we look at the impact on Business & employers, Government & Regulators, and The Economy.
Budget 2025-26:
By Liz Gibbs March 25, 2025
Budget 2025-26 is one that the government clearly did not expect to have to deliver. In Part 2 of our analysis, we look at the impact on Individuals and families.
2025-26 Federal Budget
By Liz Gibbs March 25, 2025
Part 1 of our Budget special: The Government’s big moment in the 2025-26 Federal Budget was the personal income tax cuts. Income tax cuts are a dazzling headline but in reality they deliver a tax saving of up to $268 in the 2026-27 year, with a tax saving of up to $536 from the 2027-28 year.
More Posts