Blog Layout

Pregnant worker not warned before sacking
Liz Gibbs • February 7, 2018

A travel consultant, sacked without warning while pregnant, has been awarded more than $19,000 in compensation, in part because she was found to be "a victim of a general reluctance to hire pregnant people".

Green Travel Service dismissed Bernice Zhang, after three years of employment, on 14 September last year, citing a "constant lack of performance".

Three days earlier, Zhang had been admitted to hospital due to a "pregnancy-related medical condition". Zhang told her supervisor she could not come to work and that she was pregnant.

When Zhang returned to work on 13 September, company director, Peter Sheng, sacked her verbally. She left after the meeting and Sheng gave Zhang a formal dismissal letter the following day.

Zhang applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC), saying that she was fired because of her pregnancy.

Employer's efforts "simply not good enough"

FWC Commissioner, Leigh Johns, rejected Zhang's claim that her supervisor had informed Sheng that Zhang was pregnant – leading to her being sacked – as her supervisor denied having done so.

However, Commissioner Johns found Sheng gave "unspecified and spurious" reasons for Zhang's dismissal and had never "expressly and unequivocally" told Zhang her job was at risk. Sheng had not given Zhang the opportunity to respond to the reason cited for her dismissal.

In the dismissal letter Sheng said Zhang showed "utter indifference towards the cause of the company for a prolonged period of time".

The Commissioner noted that the letter also referred to Zhang's "negative work attitude" and falsely claimed that she "refused" to perform tasks.

"No doubt Mr Sheng was disappointed with [Zhang's] attitude, but nothing in her conduct at this point justified termination of her employment," Commissioner Johns said.

The employer accused Zhang of not managing her workload and causing delays, but Zhang said that had been due to a co-worker being on leave.

The company had neither warned her nor given negative feedback before it fired her.

Sheng's efforts fell "well short of what is expected" and "his belief [Zhang] should have known that her job was on the line is simply not good enough" as she was entitled to warnings, the Commissioner said.

Commissioner Johns said Zhang being terminated at the beginning of her pregnancy had "impacted upon her ability to find alternate work in the nine months before she would otherwise be confined".

Zhang wins 18 weeks' compensation

The commission found reinstatement would be inappropriate as any chance at a productive and co-operative working relationship between Zhang and Sheng "has been lost".

Commissioner Johns said Zhang had made efforts to mitigate the job loss, but "sadly, she is the victim of a general reluctance to hire pregnant people".

Zhang said by being unfairly dismissed she lost the opportunity for paid maternity leave and accrued annual leave. She asked to be compensated for the 26 weeks she would have worked before taking maternity leave.

Commissioner Johns found the amount to be $29,000, but he deducted the three weeks' pay given to Zhang as notice of her dismissal.

Green Travel said it lost a "significant client" soon after the dismissal, and Zhang would have been let go within the next week as the business was in a "precarious financial position".

Given this, the Commissioner decided to apply a "contingency", reducing the compensation by 25 per cent.

He awarded Zhang 18.75 weeks in compensation, totalling $19,831.73.

( Bernice Zhang v GTS Travel Management T/A Green Travel Service [2017], FWC 7061 , 29/12/2017.)

Call us at Robert Goodman Accountants on 07 3289 1700 or email us at  reception@rgoodman.com.au  .  © Copyright 2018. All rights reserved. Source: Thomson Reuters.   Brought to you by Robert Goodman Accountants.  

Office open
By Liz Gibbs March 10, 2025
With thanks to all Energex and Emergency services Crew, our electricity has been reconnected and our office is open from today 11 March. We hope you and your loved ones are safe and well following cyclone Alfred. These past few days have been challenging for many, and our thoughts are with everyone affected.
By Liz Gibbs March 10, 2025
Due to a power outage affecting the entire Samford area, the RGA Practice will be operating remotely today, 10 March, until electricity is restored. Please be assured that our team remains available and can be reached at 07 3289 1700. We appreciate your understanding and support during this time. Stay safe, and we look forward to seeing you soon.
Cyclone Alfred
By Liz Gibbs March 5, 2025
As Tropical Cyclone Alfred approaches, we want to remind everyone to take necessary precautions and ensure their safety. We have received some important information that we believe is crucial to share with you to help you prepare for the severe weather conditions ahead.
Work Health and Safety (Sexual Harassment) Amendment Regulation 2024
By Liz Gibbs February 26, 2025
In a significant move to combat workplace sexual harassment, Amendments to the Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (as per the Work Health and Safety (Sexual Harassment) Amendment Regulation 2024) will soon commence on 1 March 2025.
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
The amount of money that can be transferred to a tax-free retirement account will increase to $2m on 1 July 2025.
What happens to your super when you die?
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
The Government has announced its intention to introduce mandatory standards for large superannuation funds to, amongst other things, deliver timely and compassionate handling of death benefits. Do we have a problem with paying out super when a member dies?
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
If credit card surcharges are banned in other countries, why not Australia? We look at the surcharge debate and the payment system complexity that has brought us to this point. In the United Kingdom, consumer credit and debit card surcharges have been banned since 2018. In Europe, all except American Express and Diners Club consumer surcharges are banned. And in Australia, there is a push to follow suit. But, is the issue as simple as it seems?
Babyboomer wealth
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
“Succession planning, and the tax risks associated with it, is our number one focus in 2025. In recent years we’ve observed an increase in reorganisations that appear to be connected to succession planning.” ATO Private Wealth Deputy Commissioner Louise Clarke.
Penalty for False R&D claims
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
A joint investigation involving the ATO found that, between 2014 and 2017, a Sydney business coach promoted unlawful tax schemes encouraging clients to lodge over-inflated, inaccurate or unsubstantiated research and development ('R&D') tax incentive claims
SMSF lodgement due dates
By Liz Gibbs February 25, 2025
All trustees of SMSFs with assets (including super contributions or any other investments) as at 30 June 2024 need to lodge an SMSF annual return ('SAR') for the 2023/24 financial year.
More Posts
Share by: